Comparisons
Marketplace comparisons
Side-by-side fee analysis for every pairing that matters — net payout at common price points, fee structures, and which platform fits which seller. 18 comparisons and counting.
Or skip straight to the live cross-platform tool that ranks all 11 at once.
General resale
Two of the most popular general-purpose resale marketplaces in the US. eBay has 25+ years of incumbency and the broadest buyer pool; Mercari is the simpler, more casual choice.
Two completely different selling philosophies: eBay's shipped-nationwide marketplace versus Facebook Marketplace's local-pickup-first model.
Two of the most accessible resale platforms for casual sellers. Mercari is general-purpose with predictable fees; Poshmark is fashion-specific with a flat 20%.
Two casual marketplaces with very different fee models. Depop removed its 10% seller fee in 2024 (sellers now pay only payment processing). Mercari kept its standard structure.
Local-first selling on Facebook versus shipped national selling on Mercari. Often complementary rather than competing.
Etsy's curated handmade/vintage marketplace versus Mercari's broad casual marketplace. The fee structures look different but land surprisingly close on small sales.
Depop's near-zero fee model and Gen Z fashion audience versus eBay's incumbent reach and category breadth.
Mercari's established casual marketplace versus Vinted's zero-seller-fee model. The fee math is lopsided; the question is reach.
Fashion & clothing
The eternal question for fashion resellers: list on the broad-reach general marketplace, or stay in the closet-curated social ecosystem?
Two fashion-focused social marketplaces with opposite fee philosophies post-2024: Depop went near-zero, Poshmark stayed at 20%.
Poshmark's 20% commission versus Vinted's zero-seller-fee model. The math is dramatic; the audience question is whether reach matters more.
Two Gen Z-focused fashion marketplaces with similar audiences but different fee models. Vinted charges zero seller fees; Depop charges 3.3% + $0.45 payment processing.
Sneakers & streetwear
Sneaker resellers' core dilemma: list on the platform with the largest audience (eBay) or the platform with built-in authentication and a sneaker-native buyer pool (StockX).
The authenticated sneaker duopoly. Both offer verification, both target sneaker resellers, but the fee math differs.
StockX's traditional fixed-price authenticated marketplace versus Whatnot's live commerce model.
Authenticated fixed-price selling on GOAT versus Whatnot's live-auction sneaker model.
Niche & specialty
Vintage and handmade sellers face this fork constantly. eBay's general audience versus Etsy's curated handmade/vintage buyer base.
For music gear specifically: eBay's massive general audience versus Reverb's specialized instrument-and-gear marketplace (and its lower 5% selling fee).
Don't see the pairing you want?